The initial impression is that it looks pretty slick but once you start to get into it it's just plain annoying. A classic case of style over function.
The red on black is awful after the first 15 seconds and the whole thing is just so cluttered, making it annoying and difficult to navigate. The previous layout had all the benefits of simplicity and navigation was extremely clear as a result, while still looking stylish. I want to come to a site to get the information within - surely that is the most important factor in a site of this type. It is not the same as trying to sell a particular item in a busy marketplace where the wow factor is needed to make it initially stand out from the crowd. While marketing is obviously an important factor for ITV, this is an information site and that is what is most important in order to get repeat traffic, not superficial flashiness.
I agree that some more dynamic expanding menus would improve things and would certainly be an improvement over the dog's breakfast of multipage menus and inconsitent link formats this new page has.
I also agree with everyone else that the poll should be at the top, under the counter, rather than hidden down the bottom. It also seems not to work any more. My browser displays no "radio buttons" for the options nor a "Vote" button.
The issue of resolution is also a problem. The previous site loaded fine but (in my browser at least) this new one now loads with miniature text size and I have to increse the text size to be able to read it. This is one of the very few sites where I have to do this and the annoyance factor is only going to make me less likely to visit.
Finally I think it is admirable of ITV to ask the opinion of the end-user rather than put a new site up and let everyone just deal with it. I just hope that the advice is listened to and we see some changes as a result.