Who votes for John and Edward, the whole of the republic of Ireland in some totallly misguided sense of nationalistic fervour? Those who feel sorry for Louis Walsh's recent loss? Or a bunch of sado-masochists intent upon making us all suffer???

THEY CANNOT SING!!!

So come on reveal yourselves, those who voted, please give your reasons for keeping the completely talentless twosome in whilst two singers with talent had to go through to the sing off. Perhaps you need to review your medication?

But seriously, this is a travesty, it is not cute, it is not clever, and makes me wonder how such a fickle and obviously deranged public will vote in the general election!!  

those in the republic can't actually vote.

flirtykitty, wish that applied to the X factor too, then the twins would be booked on Ryanair for Dublin instead of coming back week after week making the whole show look like a joke.

Actually I knew that people in the Irish republic don't vote in a British general election, but was sort of hoping that others would get my drift without being pedantic.

badgunky:

Who votes for John and Edward, the whole of the republic of Ireland in some totallly misguided sense of nationalistic fervour? Those who feel sorry for Louis Walsh's recent loss? Or a bunch of sado-masochists intent upon making us all suffer???

THEY CANNOT SING!!!

So come on reveal yourselves, those who voted, please give your reasons for keeping the completely talentless twosome in whilst two singers with talent had to go through to the sing off. Perhaps you need to review your medication?

But seriously, this is a travesty, it is not cute, it is not clever, and makes me wonder how such a fickle and obviously deranged public will vote in the general election!!  

please dont include me in your deranged public,I want them Twins out along with this present goverment,Wether this is your party Gunky remains to be seen as you havnt said,but you dont need to as we all have our own opinions,And I appreciate yours as i hope you admire Mine

badgunky:

flirtykitty, wish that applied to the X factor too

 that's what I was talking about.

badgunky:

Who votes for John and Edward, the whole of the republic of Ireland in some totallly misguided sense of nationalistic fervour?

 

Why don't you get your facts straight before you make such silly comments !   Viewers from the Republic of Ireland  CANNOT VOTE.    So it's BRITISH voters who have kept John and Edward out of the bottom two last week and this week.

badgunky:

Those who feel sorry for Louis Walsh's recent loss?

I doubt anyone would vote for John and Edward just because of Stephen Gately's death .Despite not having their mentor this week both Miss Frank and John and Edward both stayed out of the bottom two so someone is voting for them !

lucky leprechaun:

badgunky:

Who votes for John and Edward, the whole of the republic of Ireland in some totallly misguided sense of nationalistic fervour?

 

Why don't you get your facts straight before you make such silly comments !   Viewers from the Republic of Ireland  CANNOT VOTE.    So it's BRITISH voters who have kept John and Edward out of the bottom two last week and this week.

badgunky:

Those who feel sorry for Louis Walsh's recent loss?

I doubt anyone would vote for John and Edward just because of Stephen Gately's death .Despite not having their mentor this week both Miss Frank and John and Edward both stayed out of the bottom two so someone is voting for them !

We all feel for Louis his loss is our loss but my thoughts are with his Mum Dad,Boyzone ( That was the most moving ceromony I have ever witnessed Well Done boyzone you done your kid brother proud Just wish upon a star or dream and I'm sure we will all get there xxxxx

  I hate to admit it but the twins werent the worst on tonights show,rachel was so out of tune it was painful,she shouldve gone.

James and Edward....?,i dont see the point in having two below average Karaoke singers on,are the x factor judges seriously thinking that the public would go out and buy a record recorded by two kids with over inflated opinions of themselves.

Cmon judges,next time you recruit finalists onto the show,give a thought to the people that watch your show for good singers and not novelty comedy value.

It is obvious you have a couple of hopefuls and the rest are pub singers,you wont sell records with 95% of those finalists and with your experience ,you should clearly see that.

Twins,Rachel,Miss Frank and olly to go,then the final gets interesting,between reasonable singers.

Mark

Sorry flirtykitty was under the impression that those in the Irish republic could vote in the X factor, so I suppose that this present travesty is all down to us Brits and those from Northern Ireland.

I just wish that those wallys voting for such an abysmal pair could see that they are doing nothing to promote such talent shows by their actions, or perhaps that is their aim, to sabotage the show and make it a total circus with the tabloids ready to swoop like vultures.

Perhaps we could have a dog that howls along to the piano in the next series, or a dancing baboon!!!!

 

Why do these two think they can sing?. It is painful to listen to them. If XFactor thinks their records will be bought they are wrong. Get rid of them as soon as possible. The young laddie was put out and he was far superior to those two. GET RID

 

Aggie