why is it that louis has to point out that he thinks only simon is cheating with the song choices, last time I watched stand by me, the theme was sung by Ben E king and it didnt have that nonsense in the middle!!!! 

After tonights show I think Louis should engage brain before opening mouth, his comment tonight that the show was to find a popstar, how can he be so blind to think that the "twins" could ever be popstars is beyond me, they have less talent than my dogs and are more suited to pantomime and holiday camps than popstars.

"Gawd" as my hero Victor Meldrew would say  I DO NOT BELIEVE IT  !!!!!!!!!!!!!

haley jack:

why is it that louis has to point out that he thinks only simon is cheating with the song choices, last time I watched stand by me, the theme was sung by Ben E king and it didnt have that nonsense in the middle!!!! 

not sure how you can say that lloyd singing "stand by me" was cheating , its the theme song from a fairly well known film. the acts are allowed to try and come up with their own variation of the songs they sing and if anything shouldn't just try to copycat the original version. whereas the song jamie sang was from a fairly unknown indie movie from the late 90s.

i actually agree with louis, i could forgive it if it had been the first time but this i think is the third time that simon has gone against the spirit of the competition and allowed one of his acts to sing a song that is not really appropriate the the theme of the week. whats the point having a theme if everyone can just sing whatever they want. and what a coincidence again it was one of jamie's favourite songs he got to sing.

The song Jamie sang featured in two films and I don't think the theme was "Movies known to Louis Walsh" was it ????

well granted the original song was from the film stand by me but as the songs are meant to be from the movies, they shouldnt be singing revamped versions of the song which is not from a movie

Louis turning nasty on dermot i think will see him NOT being a judge next year

I think Louis & Simon are spoiling x factor its all about them two,  at least the girls are fair and give the true opinion. Simon is trying to sway the public to vote for his three guys but I think all a bit old, maybe Ollie has a chance LET THE PUBLIC DECIDE   

JANALICE

janalice:

I think Louis & Simon are spoiling x factor its all about them two,  at least the girls are fair and give the true opinion. Simon is trying to sway the public to vote for his three guys but I think all a bit old, maybe Ollie has a chance LET THE PUBLIC DECIDE   

JANALICE

 

It's funny but I was thinking the exact opposite .. Cheryl and Danni are two mediocre singers and that shows when they pass judgement (especially on the better singers, it sometimes chokes them to tell someone they are good) .. Louis and Simon are in the business side and I think they generally give fairer judgements.

well said

i think you must be watching a different show to the rest of us... the girls are two faced and can be very catty it's all mind games and simon's the best at it...