I don't think Tony can be compared to Richard Hillman. If I remember correctly, he didn't care who he hurt.

I think the Jekyll and Hyde character is exactly right. When he's nice, he's adorable but when he's bad....

That's precisely why it's hard to hate Tony. He killed Liam and stopped Jimmy attacking Carla because he loved her. He would have killed Roy and Hayley because he loves Maria. It's easy to hate Rosie because the only person she loves is herself

Tony is responsible as he hired the hitman. The more traditional way to deal with a cheating fiancee is dump her and call off the wedding.

Tony would probably say Liam and Carla were jointly responsible as they were having an affair. He did, however, say to Roy tonight that killing Liam was the biggest mistake of his life and he has been trying to make amends ever since by looking after Maria and the baby.

rosiet2008: herby77769:To be fair, Rosie wasn't completely innocent in the events that led up to her kidnapping. She taunted John when he first returned to the Street until he told her in no uncertain terms to stay away from him. When Fiz dumped him a second time, unsure if she could trust him, he locked Rosie in his cab and blamed her for his ...

To be fair, Rosie wasn't completely innocent in the events that led up to her kidnapping. She taunted John when he first returned to the Street until he told her in no uncertain terms to stay away from him. When Fiz dumped him a second time, unsure if she could trust him, he locked Rosie in his cab and blamed her for his troubles  - losing ...

We can all be unpredictable but in fairness, Dev's daughter is away at university and Steve's daughter is far too young for John to be interested in her, despite Sally's recent accusation. There is only one thing that will really prove if John has changed or not and that's time.

Nicola was pushing Laurel to chuck Sally out but after all the stuff with Vincent, Laurel felt sorry for Sally. I think that's wearing off now as she can see Sally is trying to take her place. Diane knows what Sally's doing but I think Vincent will uncover what she's up to. He has already told Ashley that Sally has problems but hasn't said any ...

I agree. Whatever Jo has or hasn't done, she did not deserve to be beaten like that for any reason!